Some of the times I actually load into the app but recently I’ve noticed I couldn’t load in , it just would stick in the loading screen
Little issue 4/5
There is just an issue at the moment with this great game. Whenever I finish watching an advert for currency, I don’t claim it. It just sticks with the same amount of currency I had before I watch it.
F**k you 1/5
Hi there centuries by Fall Out Boy is my favorite song ever and you put it on only VIP put it in the normal songs
TOO MANY ADS 1/5
this used to be my favorite app. but now it only gets 1 star because of the annoying ads every 5 seconds. one plays before a song, while switching difficulties, and then again after the song. 90% of my time spent in the app is sitting through the most irritating ads. if you want a piano app get one with less ads. not recommending this to anyone.
The idea of the game is good but some of the levels are too hard to be done and after I played for a while my wrist cramped and that stopped me from playing
can’t get free stuff 3/5
i just started playing this game again and it’s really fun! but when i watched the video for a free coin, it didn’t work! thanks!
Cool but glitches 4/5
I love this game but after playing it for a while, it started to really glitch out. Whenever I wanted to open up Smule Piano, it would just stay on the title screen. I could hear the music, but it wouldn’t work. So then we had to delete it and reload it 😭😭😭😭 waa I was so sad 😞
Overall, this game is super awesome, though! I recommend using it as a time killer.
Just costs too much :/ 2/5
I could see $5 a month tops, but even the $99 yearly is 8.25 a month. I can get 6 million songs from Apple Music for nearly that much. I like this app, my wife loves it, but that’s not worth 8.25 every month to us.
This game is cool because you can play the piano easily and it sounds nice but I tried to earn five coins by watching and ad and it didn’t give me my coins and I tried three times. I thought a serious app like smule would be genuine with their offers.
By This Is My Nickname I Guess
The ad system is terrible. If you watch an ad to get coins, most of the time it doesn’t give it to you. It puts an ad every time you finish a song, so it makes me want to stop the song before the last note. And again, I don’t want to watch an ad for a reward only to not get the reward. The dev team needs to fix that. Also, it’s way too easy for people to steal songs. They literally change one note and say they transcribed it.
Not worth the time 3/5
It’s pretty fun, and I don’t really mind the excessive amount of ads, I know you need to get money somehow. But my complaints are that first of all, there is very few chances to earn Smoola (or Smula, or however it’s spelled). I don’t feel like signing up for some subscription to pay for an app on my iPod, so if I want to get a new song I have to use the in-game currency. It’s extremely hard to just accumulate the currency over time, so I tried watching the ads to get 5 more Smoola, but nothing happened and I didn’t receive any money. I watched an ad, and the number of Smula I already had showed a loading sign, but then disappeared and I still had the same amount I did before. Usually I wouldn’t really care, after all, it’s just a game and I doesn’t really matter. But I really wanted to play this one song, and besides, I watch so many ads all the time, that if i got 5 Smula every time I watched one, I’d be rolling in cash. Another issue is how half the songs are only for VIPs. Again, I’m not going to pay real money just to play a song I already know how to play on a real piano.
But of course, you don’t really read the reviews at all, do you? Dozens of people like me have the same complaints, and you haven’t changed a single thing.
I’m wasting my time.
Sorry for it being so long. Those are my thoughts. I say don’t get this app if you’re going to take it seriously. If you just want some relaxation, this is fine.
Why ? Such clickbait 3/5
By lunarmoon 3
When I tapped on get “ 5 free coins if you watch a video “ it didn’t work
Magic piano 2/5
I like this app the only thing that I’m mad about it is that the white bars that appear while I’m playing a song it comes out of nowhere and it stops me for a little bit also at that time is says go faster how am I supposed to go faster in the pause menu stops me other than that I love this app
I liked the app! but Problems in this app! 2/5
By Lighting Butter
When I watched the ad to earn smoola It wont appear which frustrates me! and Sometimes the app crashes and the app wont load up the first time I had to exit the app and do it again! and the game is addictive I must admit!
It’s ok I guess🤷🏾♀️ 3/5
There are times where I really enjoy the app however, when I watch videos for coins I never get them and on top of that, the amount of ads are truly annoying.
Don’t get tricked. 1/5
They make you start with a one week free trial but will charge you after. It’s nearly impossible and I can actually play the piano. Don’t Download or buy!
I use to like this app a lot but it’s so hard for to make songs when the length of the keyboard isn’t even full. It’s so annoying
Smoola I’ve Earned Don’t Appear! 3/5
This game is a lot of fun when I’m stressed or killing time, but I refuse to pay the ridiculous prices to buy “smoola” for more songs. Which means, there’s the same few songs to play again and again.
It shows an option to watch a video to earn 5 smoola for free. But every time I do that, it doesn’t credit me my smoola????? If I’ve watched 5 videos, I should have 25 smoola. But, it shows nothing. None. Zero.
Fun game but... 2/5
I really like the game but I don’t have enough smoola(coins) to buy a song so I went to get free smoola and it says to get 5 smoola you have to watch a ad so I watched it and my coin balance stayed the same. This was very frustrating because you only get 1 coin per song that you do and the songs that aren’t free costs 25 smoola
Messed up glitches 2/5
So I tried to get the free Smoola change or whatever and I hit the free button then an add popped up of course but it didn’t give me anymore and I tried it like 5 times but it didn’t give me more so you gone have to fix that
I redownloded Magic piano but it won’t let me in the game!!! Awesome game but I need this glitch to be fixed!!!!!!!!
By whoop woo
Hey smule! I’m a huge fan of this game but there are a couple of problems that i have. The smoola takes a while to obtain and some of the ads don’t give me me reward. Also, i composed a couple of songs and my friends downloaded it and i didn’t get paid any smoola for them downloading it. I don’t know if that’s a mistake but if it’s not, i this composers should be paid at least 5 smoola for a 25 smoola song they composed. Thank you!
Doesn’t Work 1/5
I Download And Then Play And Think, “ This Is Stupid” so I stop. The next day it won’t even open. It still not open
VIP? Seriously? 2/5
This is a fun app to play, however, half the songs people actually want to play are VIP only. Who is going to buy VIP when it is so costly. $20 a month? If you do the free trial - $10 a week????? What type of system is this?
App refusing to open? 1/5
I’ve had this game for y e a r s. I re-downloaded it on my phone. Worked the first time. Then the app just stopped working after. I would only see the loading screen :/
Love The App, But It Has A Few Minor Flaws. 4/5
Ok First Of All, I Love The App, There Are So Many Songs To Play. With Practice You Can Get Good. Now, On To The Flaws. Some Songs Have The COMPLETELY Wrong Notes, And Some Aren’t Even What They Are Titled. Second, When I Watch Reward Ads To Get Coins, On Some Occasions It Doesn’t Give A Reward. That Is Extremely Annoying Because I Don’t Want To Pay To Get Songs, And There Are Songs I Want To Buy With Coins. I Would Also Like If You Would Make In A Tiny Bit Easier To Level Up. And Also, Slightly Raise The Amount Of Coins For Leveling Up. Thank You So Much For Reading My Review! -Umbreon
Needs voice improvement 3/5
Some of the singers don’t sound the same. Their voices sound strained. The adds do get annoying after awhile. Also could you more free songs please
Money pit!!!!!! Beware 1/5
This app will bleed you dry. Beware of the outrageous weekly subscription
It’s good for me and kids 5/5
I love it .it’s gust like a piano
I used to play this game ALL the time. ALL THE TIME.
But now of course, it had to make me pay for it. It makes no sense! All I want is an app to make music, not an app that makes you PAY for music!
Otherwise, it’s perfect! ;)
Might be just my phone 1/5
Okay so I don’t know if it’s just my phone or what but I can’t put three fingers down at one time no matter what only two register.
By Aries Forlorn
Lately, I downloaded this app again because I wanted something different from my other games. Overall it’s decent, I enjoy the game play but there is A LOT of bugs with gaining smoola (Coins). I watch the ads which gives you 5 coins per. I’ve watched over 10+ videos in the past two days and i’ve gotten completely nothing. I’ve tried going in and out of the app, restarting it, etc and nothing is working. Not only, but gaining smoola is extremely hard in the app. You either have to level up, or get it by downloading other games, inviting friends, being VIP, connecting a fb account, or watching ads which is currently not working!!!
Ads and more ads and no coins for videos 2/5
I’ve been playing this game for a few years now. I deleted it for a while and came back to it and was bombarded by ads. I wouldn’t mind this so much, but the fact that I have to click for 5 smule coins to watch another ad and not get the coins for it is frustrating. It’s really sad. I played the game to relax and enjoy the music, but now it’s just a frustration app.
My hand and Ads 3/5
My hand really hurts after one song then after every song or before a song there are ads I know you have to have ads on a free game to make money but the ads come on before and after a song at least make it so then the ads don’t happen every single time
I love this game 5/5
This game is so much fun and I enjoy playing the songs over and over again. But every time I try to watch an add to get coins I watch the whole thing and it loads to give me coins and then it just loads back to the same amount I had before, it doesn’t give me any coins. I don’t know why. It would be great if you could help or maybe if it’s just my WiFi or something but it’s just been doing this recently and was wondering if it was a bug. Thankyou so much for reading this.
Loading time takes FOREVER 2/5
I have perfect internet connection but it still takes so long for the app to load. If it was faster I would definitely give this four or five stars.
Not working 3/5
Not impressed with how I’m unable to collect any smoola. I’ve done everything I can and I’m NOT spending any money so I rely on the ads
Says ad for 5 smoola no 5 smoola 1/5
I do like this game a lot (even though you have to pay for almost every song) even though your pathetic company made this game I really do hate this it says ad for 5 smoola NO 5 smoola I click off an add I get nothing maybe I should stick to geometry dash
Free Smoola Vids Don’t Pay Out 2/5
Title says it....not a lot of free content but it wouldn’t be that bad if the free smoola videos paid out.
Really Great App 5/5
By Eevee Tube
I love this app so much. So What there is some ads. You can play and make your favorite songs. Great Piano practice too in a fun way.
It’s okay, complaints 3/5
By meowy kat
So, one day I tried opening the app and all it showed was the logo. I tried many times opening and closing the app, it’s not because the phone is slow either.
Also if I watch a video to get smoola it doesn’t add.
WAY too expensive 2/5
The game is alright but I’m definitely not paying $20/month for sure. I would expect maybe $4-$7/month, since it’s just a little piano game. Nothing too crazy going on, though there are some cool songs on there for people who are frivolous enough to get a subscription
App won’t open 1/5
I can play the game for one day, then the next day I try to open the app and it won’t open. Additionally, sometimes ads won’t play and I can’t advance because it freezes so much
Love it... almost 4/5
I love this app! It’s amazing to try learn the chords to up-beat or slow songs. Either way it’s challenging to do. It promotes people to learn the piano, because they can learn the chords to their favorite songs, and then play them on piano. As for myself, I am learning to play the piano. It’s a very challenging instrument to learn, and this just makes it a little bit easier.
All though this app promotes people to learn the piano, it is not a real piano. So, if you are really good at this game you cannot say you are good at playing the piano, if you only play off of a tablet or phone screen.
Overall it’s a amazing game that promotes people to learn a really difficult instrument, but it never replaces a actual piano. I hope my review matches what you think of this app.
Love this app 5/5
I love this app, my favorite app I have I on my phone, since I payed for the V.I.P., I have become much better at paying the piano, I was playing July 5 2019, it’s lagging and freezing please fix this awesome game, and to everyone complaining about the ads, if you don’t pay to become a vip the stop complaining about the ads, that what keeps these awesome games free.
I tooted hard 4/5
By the f ing best
I tooted harder
BEST PIANO GAME EVER! ( Still problems) 3/5
Just fix the waiting Developer, make it load so u know when it’s done cause ya wanna keep the people satisfied, right, I’m just gonna talk to the people, ok. Play this game after the developer answers me ok, and I said AFTER hear me AFTER!
1 star 1/5
By RIP Joeregon
So I got the game but deleted it because I was having problems and I did the free week subscription and it charged me 11.00$ even though I don’t have it anymore
Loving it, just one problem... 4/5
Ok so I’m really loving this game, but there is just one problem that is just so annyoying.
So I was just finishing up medium level on Colors by Halsey, and then I decided to try hard, so all was well the first few seconds, UNTIL... this popped up, “Why is magic piano paused?? Go to settings and turn off multitasking so your screen doesn’t slide off to another app! “ And so I went to setting and went to general, Like is showed in the picture, and I couldn’t find it! It wasn’t there! So I went back to magic piano to see the picture, and it was the exact thing I did! I couldn’t find “ MULTITASKING”
So I just went back to the song, thinking it was just a one - time thing, and the NEXT TIME I press 4 finger it pops up again! It was so annoying! So I ignored it. And then a few peachy notes later it pops up again! Ughh it was so annoying! And so I finishing the song, and because of the pop up thing, I only got 2 stars!!
But other than that, this game is awesome!
Now I know that this review is just going to be one of the other reviews, lost in the ocean of reviews, but PLEEEEAAASE! Try to fix this.